Wednesday, February 5, 2014

My Kneecap Keeps "Popping" Out

Dislocated patella
It's very common when presented with a history of one's kneecaps "popping out" for a doctor to refer the patient for physical therapy with a prescription of "Knee Strengthening/Quadriceps Exercises" and "ITB Stretching".

The medical term for this situation is "patellofemoral instability", where the patella (kneecap) has a tendency to sublux (or even dislocate) as it glides over the femur (thigh bone). I like to explain this to patients as if a train (your kneecap) is coming off of its tracks due to poor alignment.

Your patella derailing off your femur

Why does this happen?

Despite what conventional wisdom would tell you that it's weak muscles around the knee that cause the instability, it's actually a bit more involved. The usual suspects in conventional thinking to "blame" are a "weak" vastus medialis obliquus (VMO) and a "tight" iliotibial band (ITB).


In reality, the cause is more functional in that you can think of the knee joint as the middle man in-between the hip/pelvis above and the foot/ankle below. And like all middle men, they react to what's going on with the opposite ends of the chain.

When the patella subluxes, or "goes out of place", it's usually lateral of the femur. In not so severe cases, because the soft tissue structures involved are still contained, the patella usually glides back into place with a straightening and bending motion of the knee (i.e. it falls back into its track)

When the pelvis is in a less than ideal position, it will affect the function of the hip joint which will affect the function of the knee joint below. Likewise with the positioning of the foot and ankle can affect the knee joint above.

You can think of the pelvis/hips as the steering wheel, the knee and the foot/ankle as the wheels. What happens when your steering wheel is out of alignment? More wear & tear of the wheels.

Here's a typical clinical presentation:

The pelvis on the same side of the involved knee is either rotated too far forward or backward, with either way, there's a compensation at the knee where the femur (thigh bone) either wants to roll inward excessively or can't roll inward enough. Either way, the vastus lateralis (VL) quadricep muscle can be overly worked to maintain  a stable amount of internal rotation of the femur. Because the ITB covers the VL, it commonly is mistaken as the "culprit". And because the VMO wants to do the opposing motion of external rotation of the femur, it is often "out-classed" by the VL.

Can you see now why doctors prescribe "quadriceps strengthening" and "ITB stretching" for patellofemoral situations?

Everything's connected
The moral of the story is that everything is connected and with patellofemoral instability situations, I find what works is addressing what's going on above (more than below) the knee joint. Obviously every case is unique and I could go on about many other possible relationships, but what it comes down to is what is the primary driver, or the "Mother", behind the clinical presentation and the only way to find out is through a thorough clinical evaluation along with a barrage of assessment/reassessments of function.

So the next time you're in the Greenwich Village and/or Union Square neighborhood, consider coming by Michael Jocson Physiotherapy for a check up. You'll be glad you did.....


Unknown said...

Is it common for people's kneecaps to move like that? I don't think I've focused on strengthening any muscles around my knee, but my kneecap has never done that. Is it genetic?

Unknown said...

Ahmedabad is counted for having some of the best hospitals of country. Many hospitals in ahmedabad have established themselves in last few years as premier providers of world class quality professional care in medical facility environment.

RK Gupta said...

Jaipur has many leading hospitals of our country. Many Hospitals in Jaipur have recently developed with world class doctors, professional equipments including recent technology and much more.

Unknown said...

wow!Thank this meaningful
and helpful post !And I like help people make research paper

Unknown said...

Great Post !! Very interesting topic will bookmark your site to check if you write more about in the future my site said...

Even an essay writer proved my words.

Lifeatbest said...

Here know about the best hospitals in India which provide knee /hip replacement surgeries with advanced medical facilities by highly specialised doctors.

LauraMedley said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Physical exercise is the best medicine for kneecaps... atleast you can be free from the pain.. Here are some of the Best Knee Pain Exercise

Request you to practice these daily.. you can surely feel the Relief in pain of the knee.. also the exercise should be depend on whether your problem is acute knee pain or chronic knee pain

Achanta said...

Diabetes people pls follow this chart to keep the sugar undercontrol. Diabetes Hospitals in India

Morning ---two slices bread with very little lowfat butter with a cup of greentea

mid morning ---- have a cup of apples followed by a grapefruit juice with a dash of orange juice...( grapefruit is big brother of lemon and its flesh is deep red in colour and it has a very sour taste)

After one hour --- have 4 pcs of walnut or almond..

Lunch --- one small chappati + 1 small cup of rice + big bowl of veg salad ( cucumber + little carot + salad leaves + little white onion) + small cup of sabji + dal...

After two hours --- have a cup of curd...

Evening --- have a cup of green tea with some sweetless cookies or Marie biscuits

Dinner ---same like lunch or only three small chappatis with sabji and veg salads

before sleep ----- have a cup of warm low fat milk with half green apple ( if you are hungry)

Anonymous said...

Amla is a very beneficial fruits as it is rich in antioxidants and vitamin C. It is said that amla improves the immunity and is beneficial for kids too. It is however, best to use amla juice with honey because amla has a high cooling effect, and honey balances its cooling effect. Honey is also good for our health as it reduces toxins. Cardiology Hospitals in India
These days there are many types of honey available in the market and you can mix any honey of your choice with amla juice. Can someone highlight some more health benefits of amla juice with honey?

Anonymous said...

To do MBA in Singapore, work experience is must for all the MBA Colleges in singapore.

Following is the list of B-Schools in Singapore with average work experience required.

1. NUS Business School
Minimum work experience required - 2 years

2. NTU Business School
Minimum work experience - 2 to 3 years. 55% of applicants have been with work experience between 3 to 6 years.

Average work experience - 5 years

Thus in case if you wish to pursue MBA from top Singapore B Schools, work experience will be an important admission criteria.

Way2College said...

The MCAT or Medical College Admission Test, is the computer-based standardized entrance examination for admission to medical colleges in USA and Canada. It is an assess of the problem solving, critical thinking, written analysis, writing skills, and knowledge of scientific concepts and principles of the candidates.

Adam Balich said...

In the world of private investigations, we are always in a permanent search for advanced methods to reach the most favorable results, that is why the detectives in Tarrasa work diligently on each case, understanding what it is about putting an end to your concerns. Read more at detectives privados tarrasa

Benjamin David said...

SugarDaddyMeet is a dating website and an app that provides a secure platform where rich straight men can meet beautiful young women for dating and mutually rewarding relationships. SugarDaddyMeet is a thriving community of like-minded people with an active membership of over 500,000 people daily. The site is widely regarded as one of the sugar daddy dating sites. For more information at

Tim Hangton said...

We offer complete solutions for professional labeling of your products, from Hang Tag Graphic Design Stage to high-quality custom labels with exceptional design and attractive prices. Read the full info here customized clothing label

Unknown said...

The cost of bicycles in Bangladesh depends on various factors including brand, model, engine capacity, government regulations, import duties, additional costs and economic conditions. For accurate and up-to-date prices, visit the official manufacturer's website or seek advice from nearby dealers.. Look at this web-site Bike Bangladesh.